Pros and cons of buying and renting homes

• Should you embrace the flexibility of renting or invest in the long-term stability of homeownership? Is it more advisable to be cash-rich or asset-rich? To help you navigate this crucial financial decision, take a look at this general guide which breaks down the pros and cons of each option.

Traditionally, Malaysians make it their goal to ultimately buy a home. Big or small, owning a property is one of the marks of adulting and economic stability. 

Nevertheless, there is no “right” age to buy properties, because it all depends on whether you are financially ready to make such a big ticket purchase.

However, with rising property prices, shifting job markets and evolving lifestyle preferences, young adults nowadays are beginning to consider renting as an alternative, not just as a short-term solution, but a long-term preference.  

While life-long renting is a norm in some countries, Malaysians are only beginning to warm up to the idea.

It can be a complex choice. Should you embrace the flexibility of renting or invest in the long-term stability of homeownership?

Would it be advisable to continue renting indefinitely to stay cash-rich until retirement? To enjoy a lifestyle of the latest trends and fashions, indulge in expensive freshly ground coffee and state-of-the-art digital gizmos?

Or should you be asset-rich, so you can continue to enjoy a roof over your head when you are no longer able to work or generate sufficient revenue in your old age? 

Well it's down to personal preference and there is no single rule that must be shoved down anyone’s throat.

To help you navigate this crucial financial decision, take a look at this general guide which breaks down the pros and cons of each option.

Renting

Pros:

1. Lower upfront costs: Renting requires a smaller initial deposit compared to the significant down payment, legal fees and stamp duty needed when it comes to purchasing a property.

2. Fixed monthly expenses: Renters benefit from predictable monthly payments without the additional costs of property taxes or maintenance, which are typically handled by landlords.

3. Flexibility: Renting offers the freedom to move easily if job opportunities or lifestyle changes arise, making it ideal for those with uncertain long-term plans.

4. Reduced financial risk: Renting avoids the potential financial risks associated with property value fluctuations and market volatility.

5. Escape from neighbours from hell: With tenancy agreements typically bonding you to only one year (or even shorter, with an adequate notice period), it is easier to shift away from unforeseen unruly and nuisance-causing neighbours or neighbourhoods, and unlock your financial commitments to another home. 

Cons:

1. No equity building: Monthly rent payments do not contribute to property ownership or equity accumulation. 

2. Potential for rent increases: Renters may face higher rental costs over time, which can impact long-term financial stability.

3. Limited customisation: Renting often restricts the ability to personalise or renovate the living space according to personal preferences. 

4. Stability concerns: There is a risk of being asked to move if the landlord decides to sell the property or change rental terms. 

5. Limited community service participation: Tenants have no direct rights to how the community or building is managed except through the landlord’s voice.

Buying

Pros:

1. Equity building: Mortgage payments contribute to property ownership and equity accumulation, potentially enhancing long-term financial security.

2. Stability: Homeowners enjoy greater stability without the risk of rent increases or lease terminations, provided mortgage payments are maintained. 

3. Personalisation: Owning a property allows for customisation and renovations to suit personal tastes and needs.

4. Potential for appreciation: Property values may increase over time, offering the possibility of financial gains through appreciation or rental income.

Cons:

1. High upfront costs: Purchasing a property involves substantial initial costs, including a down payment, legal fees and stamp duty. 

2. Ongoing expenses: Homeownership comes with additional costs such as mortgage payments, property taxes and maintenance, which can add up over time.

3. Less flexibility: Buying a property ties you to a specific location, making it more challenging to relocate if personal or professional circumstances change, or if you can’t stand your neighbours. 

4. Market risk: Property values can fluctuate, which may lead to financial losses if the market declines.

Ultimately, the choice between renting and buying a property in Malaysia depends on various factors, including financial situation, market conditions and one’s lifestyle. There is no one-size-fits-all answer for everyone and we advise young Malaysians to always do their homework first before any transactions.

In a nutshell, renting offers flexibility and lower upfront costs. However, since rental does not build personal equity, renters should consider both future market conditions and their financial standings. Meanwhile, buying provides long-term equity and stability, but it is a riskier proposition compared to renting as it involves enormous debts and multi-year loan agreements, so you must do your homework before taking on homeownership.

Looking to buy a home? Sign up for EdgeProp START and get exclusive rewards and vouchers for ANY home purchase in Malaysia (primary or subsale)!